GPs to hold rally in London Fields as campaign builds to save surgeries from closure

Save our Surgeries march

Save Our Surgeries: Jubilee Street practice manager Virginia Patania, GP Naomi Beer and Dr Chaand Nagpaul on a previous anti-cuts march

GPs and patients from across the borough will join a protest march this Saturday as anger builds over government funding cuts to local surgeries.

The demonstration, taking place on the 65th birthday of the NHS, will start in Whitechapel at the Altab Ali Park and end with a rally in London Fields where Diane Abbott MP will give an address.

Up to 12 Hackney GP surgeries face closure and GPs fear that hundreds of thousands of East Londoners face being left with inadequate services as the surgeries that do survive will be pushed to breaking point.

This is partly due to government plans, spearheaded by Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt, to phase out the Minimum Practice Income Guarantee (MPIG) within seven years.

Since 2004, the MPIG has compensated practices in high poverty areas since care costs are generally higher there due to the link between poverty and ill health.

Dr Naomi Beer, GP at the Jubilee Street Practice in Tower Hamlets, one of the surgeries driving the campaign, said that anger was building as the implications of the cuts sink in amongst GPs, patients and the general public.

She said that Saturday’s protest aims to “raise awareness” and “make a statement” to the coalition government.

A petition started by Dr Sarah Williams, GP at Nightingale Practice in Hackney Downs, calling on Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt to reverse the withdrawal of MPIG has garnered almost 5,000 signatories.

She said: “I decided to set the petition up to ask the government to find a fairer funding formula for general practice – at the moment the formula leaves practices in inner city and rural areas non viable financially.”

Dr Coral Jones, GP at London Fields Medical Centre said: “It is perverse that NHS England is taking funding from practices in deprived areas and redistributing this to better off areas as a way of ‘equalising’ funding.

“NHS England wants to base funding for practices principally on age and number of patients.  This does not take into consideration the increased attendance rates and ill health burden on patients in deprived areas such as Hackney, and increased resources and services needed in practices to support and treat patients.”

Dr Jonathon Tomlinson, GP at the Lawson Practice in Hoxton, said: “Patient demand is much higher in poor areas than rich ones. There are 6.4 appointments per head at our practice while the national average is 4.

“Some kind of deprivation payment is needed to reflect the considerable workload in areas with particularly high levels of poverty, poor housing and social inequality.”

NHS England previously said: “As a result of these changes, the majority of GP practices in London will receive more funding in their global sum, however, a small number of practices will lose funding.”

 

 

9 Comments

  1. del on Thursday 3 July 2014 at 11:22

    The surgeries should be required to publish their accounts to support their claims.

    If they want additional state funding to fund their businesses, and are threatening that they have to close without it, they should be required to demonstrate why this is the case.



  2. Dr Naomi Beer on Thursday 3 July 2014 at 13:53

    We have published our accounts and sent them to journalists, MPs and colleagues. they are out in the public domain because we have nothing to hide and everything to demonstrate that we deliver an excellent service for amazing value for money. We have already taken pay cuts to try and keep our practices going whilst we fight for fairer funding. We cannot do this forever. By all means challenge us on providing value for money and giving care and compassion to patients, but don’t assume that what you read from government propaganda is the whole truth. Understand and value what we do or very soon you won’t have any GPs left. Dr Naomi Beer. The Jubilee St Practice.



  3. Melissa on Thursday 3 July 2014 at 13:59

    I for one will be there.



  4. del on Thursday 3 July 2014 at 21:45

    is there a link to these accounts?



  5. Alistair Newton on Friday 4 July 2014 at 19:33

    when exactly does the protest start?



  6. Ellie Broughton on Wednesday 23 July 2014 at 12:30

    @Del – lots of info here. You’ll have to mail the PM for accounts: http://www.jubileestreetpractice.nhs.uk/d/file/jubileestreet/MPIG-withdrawal-position-paper-280414.pdf



  7. del on Friday 25 July 2014 at 19:23

    There is not much information in there except how much money the partnership will lose. The critical question, especially as it is a partnership, is how much each partner takes out, and what the cost ratios look like for the support services that support the partnership. Other questions of whether you own your own premises and the yield paid etc etc. There is no indication of what the significance of £1m over 7 years is for each of the partners – a 10% reduction? 5%? 20%.

    You are claiming you should be getting the £1m or so from taxpayers over the next 7 years – and taxpayers have to write to the PM to know why?

    GPs claiming they will close is akin to a bankers move to geneva.



  8. 20goto10 on Monday 28 July 2014 at 18:42

    Er, del, PM in this case means Practice Manager, not Prime Minister…



  9. del on Tuesday 29 July 2014 at 09:07

    I did think the Prime Minister was pretty high up the chain…



Leave a Comment





This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.