News / 2 January, 2013

London Mayor to meet Dalston campaigners over ‘gated community’ fears

Boris Johnson to address local concerns over eight storey ‘gated’ development proposals

Kingsland High Street Dalston

Kingsland High Street Dalston. Photograph: Eoin O'Donnell

Mayor Boris Johnson has agreed to meet residents fighting a proposal for an eight-storey ‘gated community’ on Kingsland Road just north of Dalston Junction railway station.

The plans run contrary to council guidelines of four to six storeys for the site, which is owned by Transport for London (TfL) and located directly above Dalston Junction’s reinstated train tunnels.

Mayor Johnson committed to meet campaigners after local resident and Conservative London Assembly member, Andrew Boff, urged that previous “crazy schemes” in the area were not repeated.

“I don’t think TfL really care about Dalston,” he said. “The last time TfL got involved in Dalston we ended up demolishing heritage buildings to erect the windswept Dalston Square and building a bus stop that cost £63m where only one bus ever stops.”

As well as enclosing and reducing light to listed buildings to below British standards, the development will have minimal affordable housing and no public green space in an area of London that is in need of both, according to the campaign group OPEN Dalston.

The group’s founder, Bill Parry-Davies, has queried the benefit to the public of proposals in light of TfL’s status as a public body that acquired the sites at the public’s expense. He has also pointed out that TfL received a subsidy from Hackney Council for the development of over £1.3million.

Although the council’s costs are recoverable as part of an agreement with TfL, the amount and terms on which funds were committed are now subject to a Freedom of Information request submitted by OPEN.

Mr Parry-Davies said the proposal for a major gated community in Dalston is unprecedented and that “for TfL and Hackney to spend public money on a private development with so little public benefit is a slap in the face for Dalston”.

He added: “We pride ourselves on having a strong and diverse community and we want to maintain that in every sense and not have exclusive enclaves of better off people.”

With over 12,000 people on Hackney’s housing waiting list and rents rocketing, Mr Parry-Davies said the proposal needed to be looked at considering Dalston’s “desperate shortage of family housing”, the area’s “severe deficiency of green and open space” and the “environmental damage to heritage buildings and local character”.

Hackney Council said they have no specific policy which addresses gated developments but that they seek to resist them through building “high quality, accessible developments”.

TfL described OPEN’s statement that the intended development “created a barrier between a private development and the remainder of Dalston” as inaccurate.

They said: “Although there is no scope to create public open space within the site itself, due to restrictions of size, the application will allow for the enhancement of Dalston’s public realm by investing in a nearby green space project as part of the scheme.”

TfL admitted that their open space proposals were not compliant with the council’s Area Action Plan (AAP) for Dalston – despite the council’s design guidance for the site encouraging such uses.

The Dalston AAP also contains the recommendation for a development of four to six storeys within the proposed site. The plan is described by the council as existing to “provide confidence and certainty to developers”.

However, TfL’s development partners, Taylor Wimpey, said such parameters “are set without the benefit of seeing a detailed design and supporting technical correspondence in the form of a planning application, and are open to analysis and testing”.

The eight-storey development would contain 59 flats and the planning application shows that, across two sites, less than 10 per cent of flats meet requirements for affordable social rent.

OPEN Dalston claimed this figure is at odds with the affordable housing policy target of 50 per cent set by Hackney Council and the GLA (Greater London Authority) of which TfL is an agency.

Meanwhile, developers Taylor Wimpey cite the GLA London Plan which states that 11,600 new homes are required in the Hackney Borough by 2021.

They also quote the plan’s identification of Dalston as an ‘Area for Intensification’, and say their proposals will alleviate housing stress in Hackney through increased residential supply.

Ciaran Munnelly, a barman and resident of The Kingsland pub adjacent to the proposed development site, said that under the current plans “they might as well demolish [these buildings] and make it one big block”.

The Kingsland forms part of a terrace dating back to 1902 that includes several Grade II listed buildings.

“When they say about green space – that should be there now, for the people of Hackney from this area. But there’s nothing here – what green area is there?” said Mr Munnelly.

Nobby Clarke, a retired Dalston resident of 35 years, said he was “totally against” the proposals because the council only wanted revenue and “don’t give a crap about the man in the street’s arguments”.

“If the council want it, it’ll go through,” he added.

However, Salma Said, who runs the Snappy Snaps photographic shop situated closest to any future development at the end of the terrace disagreed, saying: “I don’t see it as a threat. Any building that brings people to the area, especially business, is a good thing.

“When it’s a positive, people should say it’s a positive and not be selfish and say why ‘aren’t we getting it?’”

Hackney Council’s public consultation, which was due to close on 20 December, has now been extended to 6 February – the date of the next Planning Committee hearing.

/ 2 January, 2013
  • £63 millions for one bus stop, and 12,000 individuals on the Hackney housing waiting list – another example of the self serving market dominated, or driven by private investments. Only 10 percent of the 59 apartments are earmark for those on the waiting list equating to mere six apartments. Six 2x bedrooms flats can house four individuals in each comfortably at the most, therefore only twenty four people can be house during the course of this project. If TfL or Hackney Council had a social conscience – it’s quite clear that a 59 2x bedroom apartments project could house 250 individuals. The question remains, who is serving who?

  • I note that OPEN Dalston’s Bill Parry-Davies is still attempting to argue for shorter buildings and more green space, whilst simultaneously claiming to be concerned about unaffordability and the housing shortage. This doesn’t make sense.

    If OPEN Dalston are to be taken seriously then they should first demonstrate some spatial and economic literacy.

  • Looknoclothes

    The reason for no public or affordable housing is because the Tories: Cameron, Osborne, Johnson and Boff et al are not putting any public money into public housing.

    Johnson talks a good talk, but the truth is they arn’t funding any housing. Look the Emporer has no clothes!

  • cock&balls

    wankers & cunts

  • cock&balls

    hate those new c*nt flats filled to the seems with self satisfied skinny jean clones ….

    ps i hate those stupid bin man hats they wear … oh how ironic !!! wankers fuk off out of hackney !

  • The Great Smell Of Brute

    Looknoclothes, why the irrelevant swipe at the Boff? It’s Pipe who’s in charge of the borough!

  • cyburn

    Oh and Hackney Labour actually cares about Dalston.

  • Meribel

    I kinda like the idea. It’s much better then some rubbish filled wasteland. Perhaps they will open John Lewis and all them fancy things will finally come to Dalston.

  • “Perhaps they’ll open a John Lewis and all them fancy things will finally come to Dalston”… Meribel, are you kidding? One of the great things about Hackney as a borough is the growth of independent shops run by locals. If you want a characterless high street then perhaps you should move to the burbs. Just a thought…


Sign up for Hackney news straight to your inbox with our weekly Friday digest - also featuring special offers, competitions and more
Email address
First Name
Last Name
Secure and Spam free...